It is Profit First, Life and Safety Second
June 12, 2025

Context

  • The tragic stampede on June 4, 2025, in Bengaluru that claimed 11 lives during the celebration of Royal Challengers Bengaluru’s first Indian Premier League (IPL) title has shaken the conscience of the nation.
  • While the incident was rooted in the euphoria surrounding a cricketing milestone, it exposed deeper systemic issues, our collective obsession with celebrity culture, the commercialisation of sports, the apathy toward public safety, and the chronic lack of accountability in governance.
  • Now it becomes imperative to examine the multifaceted causes of this tragedy and underline the urgent need for structural reforms to prevent similar disasters in the future.

Multifaceted Causes of the Tragedy

  • Disproportionate Enthusiasm and Media-Driven Hype
    • One of the primary issues highlighted by the tragedy is India’s disproportionate emotional investment in sporting victories, especially cricket.
    • Celebrations turn into frenzies, with people abandoning caution and rationality.
    • The role of social media and 24x7 television channels in fanning mass hysteria cannot be overstated.
    • They glorify such events as life-defining moments, leading thousands to congregate without adequate thought to personal safety or logistical feasibility.
    • This cultural phenomenon, where entertainment is elevated to a near-religious experience, has dangerous implications.
    • It creates a climate where people feel compelled to physically participate in mass celebrations as if their absence signifies a missed opportunity of a lifetime.
    • The result is a volatile, unpredictable crowd dynamic that becomes difficult, if not impossible, to control.
  • Profit Motives and Regulatory Lapses
    • Cricket in India has long transitioned from a sport to a lucrative industry, with massive financial stakes involved for teams, sponsors, broadcasters, and local businesses.
    • The desire to maximise profits often trumps the need for public safety.
    • Event organisers intentionally or negligently exceed venue capacities to boost earnings, despite knowing the risks involved.
    • Licenses and permissions, rather than being strictly regulated, are frequently acquired through political patronage or under-the-table arrangements.
    • The incident at the M. Chinnaswamy Stadium is emblematic of these failures.
    • Even before the stampede, the chaotic altercation between the families of senior government officials over VIP seating illustrated how entitlement and privilege undermine basic organisational discipline.
    • The contrast between overcrowded public enclosures and sparsely occupied VIP sections further reveals the inequity and casual disregard for ordinary citizens.
  • Irresponsible and Inadequate Response
    • Even in the aftermath of such tragedies, the response is often perfunctory.
    • Token compensations are offered that cannot possibly offset the loss of human life.
    • There is little introspection or structural change, and the powerful stakeholders who benefit from these mega-events remain untouched. 

Public Safety: A Neglected Priority

  • The tragedy also points to a broader national disregard for public safety, not just in stadiums but in everyday life.
  • Regulations that apply to small venues, regarding fire exits, medical facilities, crowd flow, and sanitation, are conveniently ignored when it comes to larger venues with more complex logistics.
  • The lack of enforcement mechanisms results in a systemic culture of impunity.
  • This negligence is not confined to sports arenas.
  • Public spaces like food fairs and amusement parks regularly flout safety norms. Open electrical wiring, unsafe cooking conditions, and inadequate emergency response systems are rampant.
  • One example cited was that of an amusement park ride malfunction in Chennai that left visitors stranded for hours, a reminder of how fragile and unreliable our public safety infrastructure really is.
  • Furthermore, urban infrastructure often fails to accommodate even basic human needs.
  • Most roads lack sidewalks for pedestrians, and the absence of traffic segregation leads to chaotic, dangerous situations.
  • Vulnerable populations are left exposed to high-speed vehicles, broken pavements, and stray animals, all of which contribute to the thousands of preventable deaths each year.

Accountability, the Culture of Indifference and the Way Forward

  • Accountability and the Culture of Indifference
    • Tragedies like the Bengaluru stampede are often treated as unfortunate but unavoidable accidents.
    • There is no culture of accountability, only temporary administrative actions such as suspensions or transfers, most of which are quietly reversed over time.
    • The absence of criminal or financial liability for negligence emboldens both public and private actors to continue their operations without fear of repercussions.
    • Our tendency to blame fate or karma for such avoidable disasters reflects a deep societal malaise.
    • As long as public memory remains short and the media cycle moves on quickly, there is little motivation for meaningful reform.
    • The result is a cycle of tragedy, temporary outrage, and eventual apathy.
  • The Way Forward: Institutionalising Safety and Reform
    • The time has come to institutionalise crowd management as a scientific discipline in India.
    • A comprehensive audit system should be established, involving independent experts to assess the safety measures of venues before any public gathering is approved.
    • Events driven by economic interests must be required to deposit a mandatory safety bond, which can be used for emergency preparedness and crowd control infrastructure.
    • Moreover, safety regulations must be strictly enforced, and violations must result in severe penalties, including prosecution of those responsible.
    • Public education campaigns can also help shift the culture toward prioritising safety over spectacle.
    • India, with a population nearing 1.5 billion, cannot afford to treat human life as disposable.
    • A civilised and forward-looking society must place the safety and dignity of its citizens above all else, even the thrill of a cricket match.

Conclusion

  • The stampede in Bengaluru is not merely a tragic footnote in the annals of sporting history; it is a wake-up call.
  • It urges us to reconsider our national priorities, to move beyond celebrity worship and profit-driven events, and to build a system that values every life.
  • Without structural reforms, accountability, and a fundamental shift in societal values, such tragedies will continue to occur.
  • Let this not be another incident that fades into oblivion. Let it be the beginning of a safer, more responsible India.

Enquire Now