Mains Daily Question
June 7, 2023
China’s growing influence in the South Asian Region is leading to a confrontation with the Asian countries. Highlight the reasons and suggest how India can navigate through these testing times.
Approach:
Introduction: Write briefly about the areas of confrontation.
Body: Explain the reasons for confrontation with examples of South Asian countries. Give suggestions for India’s policy manoeuvres.
Conclusion: Give a forward-looking optimistic conclusion.
Answer:
China's confrontations with neighbouring Asian nations have significantly shaped the geopolitical landscape of the region. These confrontations primarily revolve around territorial disputes, maritime claims, control over valuable resources, including oil and gas reserves, fishing grounds, and competing strategic interests.
In recent years, China's assertive actions in the South China Sea, its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), and its deepening ties with countries like Pakistan have raised concerns among neighbouring nations, including India.
Reasons for Confrontation of Asian Nations with China:
- Territorial disputes: China has pursued an aggressive approach, especially in asserting its maritime claims, including the construction of artificial islands, military installations, and the establishment of administrative structures in disputed areas.
- The territorial disputes in the South China Sea, where several Southeast Asian nations (such as the Philippines and Vietnam) have pushed back against China's territorial claims and island-building efforts in the region.
- Japan's territorial disputes with China over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands in the East China Sea.
- India's ongoing border clashes with China in the Ladakh region
- Economic confrontation: Several countries in the region have pushed back against China's growing economic influence and investment in the region e.g.:
- Malaysia and Sri Lanka's efforts to renegotiate or cancel Chinese-funded infrastructure projects.
- India's Ban on Chinese Apps and Investments.
- Tensions over Chinese Investments in Pakistan-administered Kashmir.
- Sovereignty and Autonomy concerns:
- Taiwan: There were ongoing efforts to maintain its independence and sovereignty in the face of Chinese pressure and threats.
- Hong Kong: The imposition of a controversial national security law in Hong Kong by China has drawn international condemnation. There are concerns about the erosion of Hong Kong's autonomy and its implications for regional stability.
- Cultural and ideological differences:
- China's authoritarian governance model and the promotion of its cultural values have raised concerns among countries that prioritize democratic principles and cultural diversity.
The confrontations between China and neighbouring Asian nations have broader geopolitical implications. They shape power dynamics, influence regional alliances, and impact the interests of major powers with vested interests in the region, such as the United States, Japan, and India.
Suggestions for India
- Protecting India's territorial integrity: India must maintain a strong stance on territorial issues, and a strong military presence, particularly concerning the disputed border regions of Arunachal Pradesh and Ladakh.
- Countering Chinese economic influence: To counter the economic influence that China wields in the region, including through initiatives such as OBOR, investment in infrastructure and alternative funding sources are needed.
- Building stronger ties with regional allies: Strengthen relationships with, particularly Japan, Australia, and the United States, to balance against China's growing influence. This includes cooperation on maritime security issues and joint military exercises.
- Maintaining a strong military posture: It’ll deter any potential aggression from China. This includes investing in and modernizing its armed forces, as well as enhancing its intelligence-sharing capabilities with regional allies.
- Diplomatic engagement with China: It’ll mitigate tensions and maintain stability in the region. This includes using mechanisms such as the Joint Economic Group to address economic issues and the Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination on India-China Border Affairs to assess and manage border tensions.
- Investment in emerging technologies: India should invest in emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and cybersecurity to maintain a technological edge over China, which is rapidly advancing in these areas.
- Address trade imbalance: India should address the significant trade imbalance with China, which heavily favours China, by seeking out alternative trade partners in the region and enhancing domestic manufacturing capabilities.
- Strengthen domestic manufacturing: India should focus on developing its manufacturing capabilities so that it is less reliant on imports from China. This will help to reduce the trade deficit with China and create jobs in India.
India's approach to tackling China should involve a combination of defence preparedness, economic diversification, diplomatic engagement, and technological resilience. By adopting a multi-faceted strategy, India can protect its national interests, maintain regional stability, and promote a rules-based international order in the face of challenges posed by China's actions and ambitions. Various International organizations also provide a forum for the two countries to engage in dialogue and build trust. By engaging with China on a multilateral level, India can help to ensure that China's actions are consistent with international norms and laws.