Mains Daily Question
Sept. 13, 2023
Q.1) ’The Citizen Charter plays a prominent role in ensuring citizen-centric governance, but its
Implementation in recent times has been riddled with complications. In this context, discuss the key
problems in the implementation of the citizen charter in India. (10 Marks/150 Word
s)
Approach:
Introduction: Define the Citizen Charter and give a brief background on it.
Body: Address the answer by highlighting the implementation of the Citizen Charter. Then, highlight the challenges faced in implementing the citizen charter, followed by the measures to address them.
Conclusion: Summarize the topic and conclude on a positive note.
Answer: The Citizen’s Charter is a document that outlines the service commitment of organizations or service providers towards the citizens in providing quality, high-standard services, including mechanisms for grievance redressal. In India, the concept of a Citizen’s Charter was first adopted at a ‘Conference of Chief Ministers of various States and Union Territories’ in 1997.
The role of the Citizen Charter in ensuring citizen centric governance:
Promotes Good Governance: It strengthened citizen-centric service delivery and also increased citizen awareness about their rights.
For example: Fast track issuance of certificates and affidavits in the district and Taluk headquarters. (Jan Sewa Kendras in Ahmedabad and Vadodara)
Efficient service delivery: The citizen charter enhances the efficiency and timeliness of government services.
For example: Provision of compensation as a token of commitment to customers in the event of failure to provide services.(Hyderabad Metropolitan Water Supply board)
Reduce corruption: Adhering to the citizen charter helped in reducing institutional malpractices as public bodies became more committed to public welfare.
Citizens as stakeholders: Citizens are no longer mere beneficiaries but equal stakeholders in development projects.
Citizen feedback: It incorporates citizen feedback into improving service delivery quality, thus ensuring citizen participation in the evaluation as well as the implementation of the policy.
Speedy redressal of grievances: It has provided the rights to the public for timely delivery of services and imposed obligations on the public servants to achieve it.
For example: Instructions issued to Executive Authorities for collecting a fine of Rs.50/- per day per job from the staff responsible for delays and giving it to the affected public concerned. (All Municipalities in Tamil Nadu)
Key problems in the implementation of the Citizen Charter:
One-size fits all approaches: It is uniform across all departments and thus do not inculcate their inherent differences in functioning. The exercise was carried out just because there was direction from above.
Vagueness in the charter document: The standards and norms of services were either too lax or too tight and therefore unrealistic for proper implementation.
Linguistic barrier: Citizen charters have not been prepared in the vernacular languages.
Updation of the charters:The citizen charters are not timely updated as per the ongoing changes.
Lack of training: The workforce of government organizations is unaware of the spirit and content of the charter; thus, it is not implemented in its true spirit.
Grievance redressal mechanism: Most of the citizen charters have poor or absent grievance redressal mechanisms, which hamper their effective implementation.
Lack of awareness: Information brochures, publicity materials, and pamphlets produced earlier by government organizations are mistaken for citizen charters. An awareness campaign to teach the client about the Charter is not conducted properly.
Measures to address the challenges:
Participatory process: Include Civil Society in the process, to assist in improving the contents of the Charter, its adherence, and educating the citizens about the importance of this vital mechanism.
Grievance Redressal: Develop efficient grievance redressal mechanisms that are easily accessible to citizens. These mechanisms should have timelines for resolution and should be publicized widely.
Legal Backing: Consider giving legal backing to Citizen's Charters to enforce compliance effectively. This may involve amending existing legislation or enacting new laws.
The Citizen's Charter is playing a prominent role in ensuring “minimum government and maximum governance”, changing the nature of charters from non-justiciable to justiciable, and adopting penalty measures that will make it more efficient and citizen friendly. The Sevottam model proposed by 2nd Administrative Reforms Commission for Public Service Delivery can be regarded as a standard model for providing servic
es in citizen centric governance.