Mains Daily Question
Sept. 12, 2023
Q1. Transparency and accountability are fundamental principles in governance, vital for promoting public trust and effective policy implementation. Discuss. (10 Marks)
Approach:
Introduction: Transparency and Accountability form the bedrock of a responsible and responsive government.
Body: Explain the significance of and challenges to transparency and accountability.
Conclusion: Conclude by showing the steps that need to be taken.
Answer:
Transparency and accountability form the bedrock of a responsible and responsive government, ensuring that decisions and actions are open to scrutiny, and those responsible are held answerable for their conduct.
Significance of Transparency and Accountability in Governance:
- Enhancing Public Trust: Transparent practices, such as openly disclosing government finances, build public confidence.
- For example, the introduction of Aadhaar, a biometric identification system increased transparency in welfare distribution, reducing leakage and ensuring benefits reach the intended beneficiaries.
- Effective Policy Implementation: Access to government information, enhances policymaking by enabling informed decisions.
- Right to Information Act
- Inclusivity and Participation: The Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) exemplifies this, as it provides housing for economically weaker sections, with clear eligibility criteria and an online application process, ensuring transparency and accountability in allocation. Initiatives like South Africa's community budgeting encourage citizen involvement in governance.
- Accountability to the Public: Civil society organizations and citizens can hold the government accountable through mechanisms like social audits and public hearings. In Andhra Pradesh, the MGNREGA program's social audits empowered local communities to demand transparency and accountability in project implementation. The Philippines' "Citizen Scorecards" empower citizens to rate services and hold officials accountable.
- Preventing Corruption: Transparency helps curb corruption by making government processes and decisions open to scrutiny. Measures like Brazil's "Clean Company Act" deter corruption by penalizing corrupt companies.
- Improving Service Delivery: Uganda's "Anti-Corruption Hotline" allows citizens to report corruption and inefficiencies, improving service delivery.
Challenges to Transparency and Accountability in Governance:
- Bureaucratic Resistance: Bureaucracies resist transparency due to fears of power loss, exemplified by India's delay in digitizing land records.
- Political Interference: Politicians may manipulate transparency mechanisms to protect their interests, as seen in political interference in anti-corruption agencies worldwide.
- Lack of Enforcement: Weak enforcement hampers accountability mechanisms, evident in nations with lenient penalties for corruption.
- Technological Barriers: Limited technological infrastructure impedes transparency efforts, creating a digital divide in access to online government information.
- Cultural and Socioeconomic Factors: Cultural norms and socioeconomic disparities affect transparency acceptance. In cultures valuing secrecy, open government policies face resistance.
Thus, transparency and accountability are pivotal in governance, fostering trust and effective governance. To enhance transparency and accountability, implementing real-time financial reporting, digitizing government transactions, establishing an independent ombudsman, enforcing stricter conflict-of-interest regulations etc. are the steps that need to be taken.