Mains Daily Question
Feb. 26, 2023
“There is great potential for India and Germany to improve cooperation in multiple arenas.” Examine.
Approach:
Introduction: Mention recent context due to which India german relationship remains in the news
Body: Highlight the potential of this relationship in multiple areas, also mention some challenges to the realization of this potential
Conclusion: Suggest some solutions in brief with a positive way forward
Answer:
India and Germany recently agreed on a vision statement to enhance cooperation on innovation and technology during Prime Minister Modi’s meeting with visiting German Chancellor Olaf Scholz. Both nations are willing to deepen their strategic partnership, particularly in recent times.
The potential of India-Germany relations:
- Economic potential: Germany is the seventh-largest foreign direct investor in India, and bilateral trade between the two countries in 2019–2020 was €23.39 billion, according to the Indian embassy in Berlin.
- Research and development on cutting-edge technologies like blockchain, 5G, and artificial intelligence can be done in collaboration between Germany and India. Both Germany and India agreed to establish a joint research program in Artificial Intelligence in 2019.
- Security potential: To confront common issues like terrorism and cyber threats, India and Germany should strengthen their security collaboration. Along with Germany's growing interest in using hard power, the Ukraine War has underlined the need for international collaboration in cyber security.
- Indo-Pacific Cooperation: India needs alliances in this region, especially with middle powers, where Germany can be a crucial player. Germany has also shown interest in Indo pacific cooperation by joining the Indo pacific oceans initiative (IPOI).
- Participating in exchange programs and undertaking joint initiatives can strengthen ties between India and Germany on a cultural level. There are various Indian cultural centers in Germany, and the Goethe-Institute, a German cultural institution, has branches in many Indian towns.
- Higher education and research collaboration between India and Germany might improve knowledge exchange and inter-university collaboration. A memorandum of understanding for collaborative research and educational initiatives between the Technical University of Munich and the Indian Institute of Technology, Madras, has also been inked.
- Sustainable development: India and Germany might work together to promote sustainable growth and cut carbon emissions. In September 2022, the Indo-German Green Hydrogen Task Force was established.
- Healthcare potential: India and Germany can work together to advance healthcare innovation and enhance patient access to therapies. A coordinated research effort between the two nations has also been started to create a new tuberculosis medicine.
- Take on global issues: India and Germany may use their strategic alliance to advance peace and stability. The European Union and India together conducted the world's first virtual conference in 2020, which addressed issues like climate change and the COVID-19 pandemic.
Issues involving Germany and India:
- Trade hurdles: The expansion of bilateral trade between India and Germany is hampered by trade barriers such as high tariffs and non-tariff measures. For instance, Germany places limitations on Indian agricultural products while India levies tariffs on German autos.
- India and Germany have distinct immigration laws, which might present difficulties for Indian workers and students studying in Germany. The German government has repeatedly toughened its visa requirements for people outside the European Union, including Indians.
- Intellectual property rights(IPR): There may be disagreements and legal difficulties due to India and Germany's conflicting views on intellectual property rights. A mandatory license for a cancer drug was the subject of a 2012 lawsuit filed by the German pharmaceutical giant Bayer against the Indian government, which caused controversy in both nations.
- Defense collaboration: India and Germany's lack of deep defense collaboration could harm their strategic alliance. Compared to France, Germany is less keen on maintaining a presence in the Indo-Pacific.
- Differences in cultural traditions and values between Germany and India might lead to misinterpretations and communication breakdowns. For instance, the business culture in Germany is more task-oriented while the business culture in India is more relationship-oriented.
- Other players: Germany's strategic engagement with India may be impacted by its considerable economic ties with and dependence on China.
Such issues can be further tackled by cooperation on multiple fronts, such as trade barriers, by the implementation of an institutional mechanism to ease out barriers, ensure cooperation on IP issues, and so on. Most important for a relationship is the strategic will and logic which is now present with both powers facing threats in their neighbourhood. This can be utilized to ensure substantial cooperation between the two.