Mains Daily Question
March 6, 2023
Why is the Indian economy's structural transition from agriculture to other industries occurring at a slow pace? Suggest ways for further accelerating this shift.
Approach:
Introduction: Provide recent context, like some reports highlighting this aspect of the slow pace of structural transformation in the Indian economy.
Body: Mention the reasons for such a slow pace and mention relevant solutions for a better shift from agriculture to other sectors.
Conclusion: Highlight how implementing such solutions would lead to a Vikasit Bharat by 2047
Answer:
India urgently needs a structural shift from agriculture to other sectors to reduce poverty, increase productivity, and promote economic growth. NSSO’s latest annual Periodic Labor Force Survey (PLFS) report for 2021–22 (July–June) also shows that the farm sector’s share in the country’s employed labor force is at 45.5%. That’s down from 46.5% in 2020-21 but still higher than the 2018-19 low of 42.5%. Productivity is low in this sector, so it is necessary for India to have fewer people in agriculture and more in other sectors.
Reasons for the slow structural transition:
- Inadequate physical infrastructure and bureaucratic hurdles slow down the manufacturing sector's growth, affecting its ability to create jobs, as also suggested by the Economic Survey, 2016–17.
- The lack of a supportive ecosystem for small and medium enterprises hampers their growth and innovation, making them less competitive.
- The low level of technology adoption and investment in R&D limits productivity, preventing diversified sectors of the economy from absorbing more labor.
- There are skill mismatches in the manufacturing sector because there aren't enough skilled workers and their education and training aren't very good.
- The unorganized and informal nature of the manufacturing sector makes it challenging to capture reliable employment data as also highlighted by Periodic Labour Force Survey, 2017-18
- Inadequate access to credit and finance for small and medium enterprises prevents them from scaling up and investing in technology and skills as also stated by Raghuram Rajan Committee Report, 2014
- Firms find it hard to adapt to changing market conditions and use flexible hiring practices when there aren't good labor laws and rules. Now there are attempts to rationalize labor laws, such as through the labor code.
- The lack of a clear and stable policy framework and the fact that policies and rules change often create uncertainty and make people less likely to invest.
- The low level of international competitiveness of Indian manufacturing firms limits their access to export markets and reduces their potential to create jobs, as per the Global Competitiveness Report 2019.
- India's rural development policies put too much emphasis on agriculture and not enough on non-farm activities. This makes it harder to find different kinds of jobs.
Ways to accelerate the transition:
- Increase the amount of money the government spends on infrastructure. Building better roads, railways, ports, and airports can make it easier to make things. There have been renewed attempts for investment; the budget for 2023–24 has increased spending on infrastructure by 33 per cent, to around 10 lakh crores.
- Encourage entrepreneurship: Promoting entrepreneurship can create new job opportunities and spur innovation, as it has in recent times through the Startup India initiative and other such efforts.
- Enhance access to credit: Access to affordable credit can help small and medium enterprises grow and expand their operations for example through Mudra Yojana
- Promote skill development: Training and skill development programs can enhance the employability of workers and make them more suitable for manufacturing jobs. Multiple attempts have been made here, such as through the "Skill India" initiative.
- Strengthen R&D capabilities: Investing in research and development can help create new technologies and products, making manufacturing more innovative and globally competitive.
- Encourage exports: Promoting exports can help manufacturers tap into global markets, boosting demand and production as also suggested by Foreign Trade Policy 2015-20.
- Facilitate ease of doing business: streamlining procedures for setting up and running businesses can reduce the regulatory burden and increase efficiency.
- Invest in agro-processing industries: Developing agro-processing industries can create linkages between agriculture and manufacturing, leading to greater value addition and employment opportunities.
- Encourage regional development: Focusing on regional development can lead to a more equitable distribution of growth, reducing migration from rural areas and creating new manufacturing clusters.
If India successfully implements the above solutions and shifts to a more diversified economy, it could lead to increased industrialization, higher productivity, and higher levels of economic growth. This could lead to more job opportunities, higher incomes, and improved standards of living for the population, ensuring a Vikasit Bharat by 2047.