Shenzhen Trilateral - Great-Power Politics and the Future of Multilateralism
Context:
- The meeting of US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen raises concerns about the future of the post-World War II, rules-based international order.
- Their shared scepticism towards multilateral institutions and preference for personalised diplomacy, bilateral bargaining and power politics may accelerate the shift towards a more fragmented, multipolar world order.
- Although the meeting may not signal a definitive realignment, it reflects the growing influence of great-power diplomacy over institutionalised multilateral cooperation.
Changing Foreign Policy Approaches of the Three Powers:
- China under Xi Jinping - An alternative global order:
- Since 2012, China has pursued a more assertive and expansionist foreign policy, seeking a greater role in global governance.
- It has established or strengthened alternative institutions and arrangements, including AIIB, BRI, RCEP, and BRICS, where China has emerged as a dominant influence.
- Paradoxically, China's economic rise has also benefited significantly from Western-led trade liberalisation, contributing to growing protectionist sentiments in the US.
- Russia under Putin - Multipolarity and spheres of influence:
- Russia has consistently challenged the US-led international order and advocated a multipolar world.
- Its actions include the 2014 annexation of Crimea and the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, challenging established principles of sovereignty and territorial integrity.
- It advocates negotiated spheres of influence for major powers and has strengthened strategic, economic and security partnerships with China and Iran.
- US under Trump - America First and unilateralism:
- Despite being the principal architect and defender of the post-war international order, the US under Trump has increasingly questioned its institutions.
- Trump has criticised the WTO and NATO, favouring bilateral negotiations over multilateral arrangements.
- His tariff wars have weakened confidence in rules-based global trade and encouraged unilateral economic coercion.
- Personalised diplomacy and direct engagement with national leaders have increasingly bypassed established diplomatic institutions.
Shenzhen Trilateral:
- The meeting has drawn comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference, where the US, Britain and the Soviet Union discussed the post-war international order.
- However, unlike Yalta, the Shenzhen meeting took place amid intensifying geopolitical rivalries.
- The joint statement emphasised maintaining strategic stability and international security, suggesting an attempt to identify common ground rather than conclude a comprehensive strategic agreement.
Four Major Areas of Understanding and Their Symbolism:
- UN reforms:
- The leaders supported reforms to make the United Nations more responsive to global challenges.
- However, the nature and extent of proposed reforms remain unclear, despite the UN's outdated representation of contemporary geopolitical realities.
- Energy security: They proposed increasing the production and supply of refined petroleum products. This is significant for India, a major global refining hub, particularly amid disruptions to international energy supplies.
- International Criminal Court (ICC):
- The leaders cautioned against the alleged misuse of jurisdiction by the ICC and similar bodies.
- This aligns with Russia's opposition to the ICC arrest warrant against Putin over alleged war crimes. None of the three countries is a party to the Rome Statute.
- Nuclear security:
- They agreed to engage in dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing nuclear proliferation.
- However, this does not amount to a commitment to reduce their own nuclear arsenals. The reference to non-proliferation also carries implications for Iran.
- Historical symbolism:
- Xi invoked World War II as the backbone of the global anti-fascist struggle, while Putin highlighted the three countries as victorious powers.
- These references underline the continuing importance of the 1945 legacy in shaping their geopolitical narratives, including messages directed towards Japan and Europe.
Implications for Multilateralism and Global Governance:
- Shift towards personalised great-power diplomacy:
- Institutionalised cooperation, collective deliberation and common norms may increasingly give way to direct negotiations among powerful leaders.
- Excluding Ukraine and European powers from discussions concerning the Ukraine conflict risks legitimising decisions by a handful of powerful states over affected countries.
- Emergence of a new global hierarchy:
- The meeting reinforces perceptions of multipolarity by bringing three major powers together.
- However, it may replace the existing hierarchy with another dominated by powerful states rather than establish an inclusive international order.
- Marginalisation of international institutions:
- The growing preference for leader-level negotiations could weaken the role of institutions in resolving disputes and establishing global norms.
- Institutions such as the UN may increasingly become platforms for endorsing decisions already negotiated outside their frameworks.
- Fragmentation of multilateralism:
- Rather than witnessing the complete decline of multilateralism, the world may experience competing versions of it, shaped by different power centres and strategic interests.
- The role of emerging economies and the Global South in these alternative arrangements remains uncertain.
India's Strategic Priorities:
- Strategic autonomy: Maintain independent foreign policy choices and avoid excessive dependence on any single power bloc.
- Diversified partnerships: Strengthen cooperation with like-minded countries through platforms such as the Quad, BRICS and G20.
- Institutional reforms: Advocate democratisation of global governance, particularly reforms in the UN Security Council, to provide greater representation to the Global South.
- Economic resilience: Strengthen domestic manufacturing, supply-chain diversification and energy security to reduce external vulnerabilities.
- Technological capabilities: Invest in indigenous research, critical technologies, semiconductors and defence production to enhance strategic autonomy.
- Constructive multilateralism: Support inclusive, rules-based international cooperation while engaging pragmatically with competing power centres.
Conclusion:
- The Shenzhen trilateral may not mark the end of multilateralism, but it reflects its transformation.
- Hence, the emerging international order could witness multiple competing forms of multilateralism rather than a single universally accepted framework.