Beyond Fire Counts: Why India Needs Better Tools to Measure Stubble Burning
Why in news?
Satellites have recorded 16,070 farm-fire incidents across northern India this kharif harvesting season, but experts warn the actual scale of stubble burning could be much higher.
At a high-level inter-ministerial review last month, the Centre acknowledged gaps in satellite-based monitoring and directed district authorities to intensify ground patrols after 3 pm — when satellite coverage is largely unavailable.
This has reignited debate on whether India needs a more robust, standardised method to measure stubble burning’s true extent.
What’s in Today’s Article?
- Why Stubble Burning Happens and Why It Matters?
- How Farm Fires Are Currently Tracked?
- The Core Problem: What Satellites Are Missing
- The Paradox: Fewer Fires Detected, More Area Burnt
- Why Even BA Mapping Has Limitations?
Why Stubble Burning Happens and Why It Matters?
- The post-monsoon period gives farmers only a narrow 10-20 day window (October to mid-November) between paddy harvesting and wheat sowing — prompting large-scale burning of crop residue.
- This severely degrades air quality across the Indo-Gangetic Plain.
- As per IITM (Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology) data, stubble burning can contribute over 30% of Delhi’s PM2.5 during peak season.
- PM2.5: Particulate matter ≤2.5 micrometres in diameter — a microscopic mix of solid particles and liquid droplets (dust, soot, smoke, chemical aerosols), sourced from vehicles, industry, power plants, and natural events like wildfires.
How Farm Fires Are Currently Tracked?
- India relies on daily thermal-anomaly observations — significant temperature deviations detected by sensors aboard polar-orbiting satellites like Aqua, Suomi-NPP, and Terra (operated by NASA/NOAA).
- Critical limitation: These satellites detect fires only during fixed overpass windows, mainly 10:30 am to 1:30 pm.
- Suomi-NPP (with VIIRS sensor): passes at ~1:30 pm, detects fires at 375-metre resolution.
- Aqua (with MODIS sensor): coarser 1 km resolution; its overpass has shifted from 1:30 pm to ~4 pm since 2023, capturing some later fires.
- This fire-count data feeds directly into IITM’s emission estimates for Delhi-NCR air quality forecasts — and influences policy decisions, including triggering the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP) when air quality worsens.
The Core Problem: What Satellites Are Missing
- A November 2025 ISRO Space Applications Centre study found peak farm-burning activity has shifted to late afternoon/evening in Punjab and Haryana — outside standard satellite detection windows.
- Analysts noted that VIIRS-based estimates are “inadequate in capturing the near-totality of fire incidences” in Punjab.
- A 2019 Columbia University-affiliated study found MODIS missed over 90% of fires in northwest India — due to:
- Short duration (many fires last under 30 minutes, occurring entirely between satellite passes).
- Partial burning (common in Haryana), which produces weaker thermal signals harder to detect.
- Using South Korea’s GEO-KOMPSAT-2A satellite, a 2026 study found a sharp spike in fires after 4 pm — a trend building since 2022.
- Crucially, aerosol pollution rose between 2022-2025 even as official satellite fire counts fell — exposing the detection gap.
- Cloud cover is another persistent challenge, frequently flagged by the Indian Agricultural Research Institute, which obstructs satellite observation over northern states.
The Paradox: Fewer Fires Detected, More Area Burnt
- At an October 2026 inter-ministerial review, authorities called for ground surveillance to supplement satellite data, especially post-3 pm.
- iFOREST (International Forum for Environment, Sustainability and Technology) assessment revealed a striking contradiction:
- Haryana: Recorded fire incidents fell from 1,406 (2024) to 662 (2025), but satellite-derived Burnt Area (BA) actually increased from 7,117 sq km to 8,812 sq km.
- Punjab: Incidents fell from 10,909 to 5,114, while BA fell much less sharply — from 23,262 sq km to 19,757 sq km.
- This shows fire-count data alone can be misleading — fewer detected fires don’t necessarily mean less actual burning.
Burnt-Area (BA) Mapping: A More Reliable Alternative
- Unlike active-fire detection (which only captures fires at the moment of satellite observation), BA mapping detects changes to land surface left behind after burning.
- Burning alters how ground reflects sunlight, especially in near-infrared and shortwave-infrared wavelengths — creating “burn signatures” detectable even after smoke clears.
- Key indices used:
- NDVI (Normalised Difference Vegetation Index): measures vegetation greenness.
- NBR (Normalised Burn Ratio): compares near-infrared/shortwave-infrared reflectance; a fall in NBR signals vegetation damage/burnt surface.
- As per the experts, burnt area signal is weaker but lasts longer. BA products are much more accurate than [active fire detection] to estimate total area affected.
- ESA’s Sentinel-2 satellites (used for internal BA assessments in India) offer up to 10-metre resolution and revisit areas every 5 days.
Why Even BA Mapping Has Limitations?
- Crop-residue fires are smaller and less intense than wildfires (less biomass involved), making medium-resolution sensors (MODIS, Sentinel-3) less sensitive to agricultural fires.
- Harvesting itself alters a field’s spectral signature — exposing soil and residue — which can resemble burn signatures, making it hard to distinguish genuinely burnt patches from merely harvested fields.
- The short gap between harvesting and next sowing means burn scars change quickly as fields are ploughed/prepared, while cloud cover further limits usable imagery.
- Satellite-derived BA maps require regular validation against higher-resolution imagery for accuracy.
Conclusion
India’s reliance on active-fire counts alone risks significantly underestimating the true scale of stubble burning, given satellite blind spots around timing, fire intensity, and cloud cover.
Combining ground surveillance with burnt-area mapping — despite its own technical challenges — offers a more accurate, holistic picture, essential for designing effective pollution-control policies across the Indo-Gangetic Plain.